Free
Le Déluge of SEC comments keeps flowing
I was out of the country last week in a remote part of Costa Rica and tried my hardest to get off the grid. Still, it was hard to ignore the growing number of comment letters coming into the SEC on its proposal to let companies eliminate 10-Qs.
Each time I checked, the number of letters seemed to grow exponentially. The SEC has struggled to keep up with the deluge of letters, which has led to more than a bit of controversy among people who are watching this proposal carefully because letters seem to be posted in big batches and there’s no rhyme or reason behind which letters are made publicly available when. Late Tuesday, the number of letters nearly doubled to just over 123,000 from nearly 68,000 a day earlier. These sorts of batch dumps prompted the SEC to issue a notice late yesterday, noting that “a large number of comments have been received for this proposing release, and we are working on posting them.”

While most of the letters have been from individuals (as well as yours, truly, whose comment letter is here), there have been a few notable letters from big companies. This one, from Eli Lilly, is one of the few letters from a very large company that not only supports the proposal, but says that the company, which has a market cap over $1 trillion, plans to move to semi-annual reporting if the SEC’s proposed rule passes.
Another letter that jumped out at me was from hedge fund giant Citadel, whose July 6 letter, first became available on July 13, a week after it was submitted. In the 26-page letter, Citadel Managing Director Stephen John Berger takes apart the proposed rule piece by piece:
It would severely undermine, rather than strengthen, our markets.1 It
would make the U.S. capital markets less transparent, less efficient, and less competitive, deprive investors of timely information, increase the cost of capital, and erode one of the core features that has helped make the U.S. public markets the gold standard globally. It should be withdrawn.
Ohio State University Professor Tzachi Zach has been trying to keep up with the constant stream of letters and has released some very interesting data which shows that at least so far, over 99% of the comments are opposed to the proposal. But so far, Prof. Zach has only been able to process about 1/3 of the letters due to the massive numbers. Yesterday, he added a note to the top of his research stating that he had run out of tokens to process the letters until next Sunday.
I’ve skimmed a fair number of the letters and it’s hard to imagine that those in favor of eliminating the 10-Q break 5%, which makes this more of a political problem than anything else. As I’ve said all along, the SEC has the power to push this proposal through. But with that many comments agains the proposal — more comments than on any other single SEC rule in the history of the agency — someone is undoubtedly doing the calculations as to whether doing so makes political sense.

