Free
Apple’s proxy goes on a diet
It’s January, which for many people means promises to lose weight, eat better and spend hours at the gym. I thought about this the other day when I was digging into Apple’s proxy, which was filed on Jan. 8. One of the first things that jumped out at me was that there was only one — count em’ one — shareholder proposal on the proxy this year.
Last year, there were four shareholder proposals. The year before that, there were five. As a result, Apple’s proxy this year was 15% slimmer, if you will. This year, the proxy was 84 pages, compared with 98 pages for 2024.
Just to be clear, this isn’t an accident. It has to do with everything that happens before a proxy is filed. In a nutshell, companies have a certain amount of discretion over what types of proposals have to be put before shareholders and it’s not uncommon for lawyers to write lengthly letters challenging a shareholder proposal. Looking at SEC data that tracks this, it looks like Apple was able to keep five different proposals off for a variety of reasons, leaving just one from the National Center for Public Policy Research on Apple’s business dealings in China.
To be clear, Apple isn’t the only company doing this. If you look at the SEC’s Correspondence page, you’ll see a virtual who’s who of large American companies doing much of the same. The Walt Disney Co., which hasn’t filed its proxy yet, seems to have also been successful in keeping five proposals off its proxy (we’ll check back once the Disney proxy is filed at the end of this month).
One thing making this easier for companies (or at least their outside lawyers) is a statement that the SEC issued on Nov. 17 that simplifies the process for keeping a shareholder proposal off the proxy. In the past, companies had to essentially get a seal of approval from the SEC to keep a proposal off. But the SEC is basically saying that if a company wants to exclude a proposal, that’s ok with them.
Could the shareholder proxy process use a much-needed makeover? Absolutely. As I’ve written before for Bloomberg and others, the shareholder voting process has become an exercise in frustration because even when a shareholder proposal passes or a director doesn’t receive the majority of votes, most companies are under no obligation to do anything about that, which seems like an exercise in futility.
Clearly, it’s a fine line, especially in this politically charged environment where both liberal and conservative based groups are using shareholder meetings to press their agendas. Still, there should be some sort of reasonable way to give shareholders a chance to voice their concerns without having to roll the proverbial rock up a steep hill. Apple clearly has the legal bench to keep a shareholder proposal off of its proxy. But just because it can, it doesn’t mean that it should.

